1-2 slices of thinly sliced or finely diced ham or smoked salmon
1-2 slices thinly sliced cheese (I used Swiss and havarti)
1/2 cup finely diced bell pepper (red, orange, yellow, green, whatever)
2 scallions finely diced
2-4 Tablespoons of olive oil
Salt and pepper to taste
Prep is pretty easy for this. Crack some eggs and beat them in a bowl. Dice up your peppers and scallions and mix them right into the beaten eggs. Get out your ham and cheese. Or your smoked salmon. I tried this with ham and swiss, but I also tried it with smoked salmon and havarti. The smoked salmon, while very delicious, lent a pinkish hue to the final product that I didn’t love because I mixed the smoked salmon into the egg mixture. I don’t recommend doing it that way. The key details you’ll want to keep in mind is that you want a small amount of ingredients, and you’ll want to add the meat and cheese before getting too far into your roll. Over-stuffing will lead to burst omelets, and nobody wants that.
If you’re an expert at tamagoyaki, you have a tamago pan, probably a non-stick one. Those pans are rectangular and help you make a beautifully rectangular omelet, but I didn’t have one so I used a 12-inch non-stick pan.
Worried about under-cooking eggs? Don’t be.
There is a detail to consider before you start: Do you want your omelet to be yellow or brown? I like my omelets yellow, so my goal is to work quickly and not stall out and not overcook my omelet. There is really no way to undercook this; if it’s able to be rolled up, it’s cooked enough.
Get ready to repeat yourself
Swab on some olive oil with a brush or a paper towl. Pour in about 1/6th of the egg mixture into the pan. Basically, you’re going to coat the pan with a thin layer of egg. If you want to add ham or salmon or whatever, do it in this first roll and make sure that whatever you’re adding is thin or diced! Once the egg begins to set, using chopsticks or a rubber spatula (frankly, at times it is best to use both together), begin to roll the edge farthest away from you toward yourself. Do this slowly and try to keep it cylindrical if you can, but it’s okay if it becomes more like a brick shape. You want to go slowly because you don’t want to tear the omelet.
Once you have rolled up the omelet, push it back to the far edge of the pan. Get the olive oil towl out and apply another thin layer of olive oil. Pour about the same amount of egg mixture you poured last time into the pan. This is important: Your goal is to carefully lift up the omelet so the new egg mixture will pour underneath your rolled omelet and combine with the already cooked omelet. This will ensure that your next roll will be seamless and even. Once the egg begins to set, you’re going to continue rolling.
Once you roll up round two, you’re going to repeat this again until you feel like you’re done. I came to the conclusion that three rounds is about the right amount for me. I tried larger omelets, and I tried a one-egg omelet, which was cute, but 3 seems to make sense. After all, that’s the size of a typical 3-egg omelet. Deep down in my soul I feel like doing it with 4 pours using very thinly poured stages of egg mixture would be perfection. Maybe next time.
Once you’re omelet is done, very carefully roll it out onto a cutting board or plate and let it rest. You will NOT cut it while it’s hot or it will fall apart. This is great for brunch because you can cook a bunch of these and they can sit around until your guests arrive (or while you make, for example, hash browns). Once you’re ready to serve, cut it up into 4 or 5 rounds and plate it.
As I say, this was my first time trying this out, and I had a few mis-steps along the way, but I ultimately figured it out and came up with some nice omelets that were different and quite tasty. I’d be very interested to hear if others have ever tried anything like this or if they try it and have any suggestions about how to make it better.
I didn’t add milk or water to my eggs. You can try that if you want but I wouldn’t dilute it too much as you don’t want your egg roll omelet to thin out and tear easily while rolling. I also don’t use butter because that will brown the egg, and I don’t really like browned omelets. You do it as you like it.